Skip to content

20 Etsy Jewelry Items That Will Become Instant Heirlooms

The perfect pieces for everyone on your list.

Whether you're looking for a wedding band or a pair of earrings to give your girlfriend for her birthday, buying the perfect item of jewelry is rarely an easy feat. Not only do you have to get the size and style right, but in most cases, you need a hefty budget to score something stunning. Luckily, for those who want unique pieces without the high price tags, there's Etsy. On the site, countless independent artists sell gorgeous, handmade baubles that won't break the bank. So, read on to discover the best jewelry the marketplace has to offer. And for more great gifts the members of your inner circle are sure to love, check out these 27 Practical Housewarming Gifts for the New Homeowner.

Best Life's editors have scoured the internet to bring you the best products out there, and we're hoping you'll love them as much as we do. Full disclosure: we may earn a commission for anything you purchase through links on this page, but that doesn't mean you'll pay more for them (we'd never do that to you!). Pricing and availability are accurate as of the piece's initial publication date, but it's the internet and we can't guarantee that these sweet, sweet deals will last forever, so scoop them up before someone else does!

This three-initial necklace

b m f initials on gold chain, Etsy jewelry

Looking for a great personalized gift that isn't a traditional (and slightly outdated) nameplate? Then scoop up this gorgeous three-initial necklace, which is a bargain buy at just $38.

$38 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

This freshwater pearl bracelet

pink pearl bracelet, Etsy jewelry

There's nothing that says elegance quite like pearls. However, not everyone wants the full debutante look associated with a pearl necklace. If you want to give that special someone a bauble that's a little bit less buttoned up, this freshwater pearl bracelet certainly fits the bill. And for more great budget-friendly presents, check out these 30 Gifts Under $30 Your Girlfriend Will Love.

$44$40 at Etsy
Buy Now

This opal star necklace

gold and opal star on chain, Etsy jewelry

Think gemstone jewelry has to break the bank? Think again. With its gold-plated brass chain and a beautiful opal in the center of its starburst pendant, this necklace looks like a million bucks, but will set you back just $30.

$30 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

These sapphire studs

two pairs of blue sapphire stud earrings, Etsy jewelry

No matter what your friend's style is, a pair of basic studs is sure to suit it. And these sapphire ones are the perfect pop of blue to brighten up any outfit.

$80 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

This gold-filled locket

hand holding gold locket, Etsy jewelry

Whether its recipient keeps it empty or fills it with family photos, this simple yet elegant locket is sure to be treasured for years to come. And for more sentimental presents, check out these 20 Adorable Mother/Daughter Gifts They're Sure to Love.

$56 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

This sterling silver branch ring

silver ring that looks like a tree branch, Etsy jewelry

Though Tiffany bamboo jewelry is gorgeous, it's undeniably pricey. The good news? You can get this similar and equally stunning ring on Etsy for just $39. And since it's so simple, it works just as well as an everyday ring as it does as a wedding band for recipients of any gender.

$39 at Etsy
Buy Now

These diamond circle earrings

round diamond earrings, Etsy jewelry

Understated, shiny, and well-priced, these tiny diamond circles are just the right amount of bling to give any outfit a little more sophistication.

$167 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

This emerald necklace

gold necklace with emeralds, Etsy jewelry

Want to give that special someone a piece of jewelry that goes just as well with cocktail party attire as it does with jeans and a T-shirt? Then look no further than this genuine emerald station necklace. Its thin chain and understated elegance makes it perfect for layering or for being worn alone as a subtle but snazzy accessory.

$75 at Etsy
Buy Now

These diamond spider earrings

silver spider earrings with diamonds in them, Etsy jewelry

Looking for the perfect Halloween present for your spooky sweetheart? These diamond-and-silver spiders are super stylish with just a hint of a ghoulish vibe.

$80 at Etsy
Buy Now

This rose quartz cocktail ring

woman's hand with pink nail polish and large rectangular pink stone, Etsy jewelry

Who says you need to wait until you're engaged to sport a huge statement ring? This rose quartz cocktail ring is a commanding presence on your hand—no proposal necessary.

$48 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

This diamond star necklace

diamond star necklace, Etsy jewelry

Delicate diamonds and your choice of yellow, white, or rose gold make this star pendant a thoughtful (and stylish) gift anyone would be glad to wear. And if you're looking for the ideal push present, check out these 15 Essential Gifts for Pregnant People.

$233 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

These raw aquamarine earrings

raw aquamarine earrings in gold prong settings, Etsy jewelry

While aquamarine jewelry can be pricey, you can still snag a birthstone gift for the March baby in your life without breaking the bank. Case in point: These gorgeous raw aquamarine studs start at just $34.

$34 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

This skinny gold-filled bangle

thin gold bangle, Etsy jewelry

Small enough to accompany your usual arm party but flashy enough to stand on its own, this slim bangle is a sophisticated accessory you can wear with practically anything. And for more outfit add-ons you can't live without, check out these 15 Killer Style Accessories You Never Knew You Needed.

$39 at Etsy
Buy Now

This moon and heart necklace

gold moon and heart on gold chain, Etsy jewelry

Whether you're buying it for your mom for Mother's Day or as a birthday present for your significant other, this heart and crescent moon combo is an adorably sentimental gift any recipient is sure to love. It can even be customized with additional hearts, perfect for multi-kid families.

$26 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

This gold ball necklace

gold ball on gold chain bracelet, Etsy jewelry

Know someone who loves the '80s, but isn't quite ready to break out their best "Choose Life" T-shirt in public? Then scoop up this gold ball necklace, which gives off a distinctly retro vibe without an ounce of neon or Aqua Net.

$92 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

This yellow gold and diamond baguette ring

gold band with rectangular diamond, Etsy jewelry

The perfect non-engagement diamond ring exists—and it just so happens to be as beautifully designed as it is perfectly priced. At just $103, you can finally give that special someone a gorgeous diamond without decimating your finances.

$138$103 at Etsy
Buy Now

These skull studs

two gold skull earrings, Etsy jewelry

Who says goth can't be glam? These gold skull studs are the perfect mix of stylish and spooky, making them a great addition to a Halloween costume (or just an eerie addition to any year-round look).

$48 at Etsy
Buy Now

These bee hoops

woman wearing gold bee earrings, Etsy jewelry

Whether you're giving them to an amateur apiarist or are just handing them off to your honey, there's practically no way these earrings could bee any sweeter. And for more presents for the animal lover in your life, check out these 20 Perfect Accessories for Cat Lovers.

$17 at Etsy
Buy Now

This sterling silver beaded bracelet

silver beaded bracelet with rocks behind it, Etsy jewelry
Etsy jewelry

This beaded sterling silver bracelet looks like it cost you an arm and a leg. The good news? You can snag it for as little as $32, so you won't have to start selling any body parts to afford it.

$32 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

These black diamond hoop earrings

two pairs of gold hoops with black diamonds, Etsy jewelry

What you want: to buy diamonds for someone special. What you have: under $200. What you get: this gorgeous pair of black diamond hoops, sure to become a prized possession of anyone who receives them. And for more presents everyone on your list will love, check out these 27 Relaxation Gifts You'll Want to Keep for Yourself.

$60 and up at Etsy
Buy Now

To discover more amazing secrets about living your best life, click here to follow us on Instagram!

Sarah Crow
Sarah Crow is a senior editor at Eat This, Not That!, where she focuses on celebrity news and health coverage. Read more
Filed Under