Cher Started Dating Warren Beatty at 16 After He Almost Hit Her With His Car

Cher and Beatty met in an unusual way.

In the early '60s, Cher was living with her family outside Hollywood, full of ambition and ready for the life outside high school where she was sure fame awaited her, according to the 2001 biography Cher by Cheryl Napsha and Connie Berman. Within a year, she would drop out and start performing at clubs on the famed Sunset Strip—and according to a 2018 interview with Elle, that was precisely where she headed as soon as she got her driver’s license. She was passing the Strip’s famous celebrity hangout Schwab’s Pharmacy when she said she was nearly run down by a man in a white Lincoln convertible. Shaken by the near-accident, she went off on the driver. “Are you nuts?” she said to him before recognizing the man who had almost made her wreck her stepfather’s car. “Then I looked at his face, and I thought, my god, it’s Warren Beatty.”

She was 16, and he was 25.

At the time, Beatty was a 25-year-old heartthrob fresh from his big breakout opposite Natalie Wood, with whom he also had an off-screen romance, in 1961’s Splendor in the Grass. Recounting the same night in her 1998 memoir The First Times, Cher recalled being charmed by the actor. Memories of the near-crash were quickly in the past as he apologized, bought her cigarettes, and invited her to get something to eat. "Warren was unbelievably handsome and funny,” she wrote. “He had charm coming out of every pore, which is always a deadly combination."

For more celebrity relationship drama sent right to your inbox, sign up for our daily newsletter.

He wooed her with cheese, crackers, and soda.

Although she had a midnight curfew, Cher recalled feeling that she basically owed it to the women in her life to take Beatty up on his offer. "I remembered how crazy my mother was about him, and also my best friend, Penny, so if I didn't go and get something to eat with him, would I in effect be cheating these women?," she wrote. As she contemplated this question, Beatty took the chance to change the invitation. "Do you want to go to my house and get something to eat there?" he asked, according to her. Cher followed him to his glamorous home, briefly wondering if Wood had also visited him there as she entered. She wrote that Beatty served up cheese, crackers, and a Coke as she braced herself for what she “knew was coming.”

Only one of her parents was horrified.

According to Cher's book, it wasn't long before Beatty kissed her. Although she didn’t spell out what happened next, she did write that Beatty kept her out until 2 a.m. that first night. The teen arrived back home to find her stepfather Gilbert Lapiere waiting up and “pissed,” and the next day, Cher explained to her late mother Georgia Holt that she’d gone to dinner with the movie star, leaving out the rest of the story.

According to Elle, her parents forbade her from seeing Beatty again. But Holt changed her mind after Beatty himself called to convince her that everything would be fine. "I don't know exactly what he said, but I remember that she was very impressed," Cher recalled in The First Times. “He definitely charmed her.” Gilbert was apparently less impressed. "I don't care who this guy is," he asked, per Cher. "What is he doing, going around with a 16-year-old girl?"

He wasn't concerned about her age.

Cher admitted to her parents that she hadn’t given the star her real age. When the fact of her being 16 was shared with Beatty in yet another conversation with her mother, he simply asked Cher if it was true. When she said it was, he told her it “didn’t make any difference,” according to her memoir.

They kept seeing each other ("We'd take showers and talk, and he'd tell me great stories about all the things he was doing, and he'd laugh at my stupid stories," she wrote.) until shortly before she met a 28-year-old assistant to producer Phil Spector named Sonny Bono that November. As for whether finding out her age ever changed anything for Beatty, Cher wrote in her memoir, “It actually seemed to make him like me more. (Duh—of course.)"

She later called Beatty “a disappointment.”

Cher wrote that although she didn’t love him, she thought of Beatty as "a famous, charming movie star that I'd hang out and have sex with." That lack of romantic connection made their time together “a disappointment,” she told Playboy, as quoted in Suzanne Finstad’sWarren Beatty: A Private Man from 2005. "Not that he wasn’t technically good, or couldn’t be good, but I didn’t feel anything,” the singer admitted to the magazine.

In 1990, she provided some unfortunate accounting for the liaison to Vanity Fair, saying, “Warren has probably been with everybody I know, and unfortunately I am one of them … but I had pretty low self-esteem, and I had never really been around men.”

His affair with Cher would hardly be the last case of Beatty being linked to a teenager. Decades later, Rob Lowe would write about the time Beatty implied he was sleeping with Lowe’s then-girlfriendMelissa Gilbert, who said in her own memoir that she was 17 when Beatty first approached her. In a 1991 interview in Rolling Stone, the late Carrie Fisher claimed that the actor approached her four times on the set of Shampoo, when she was 17, with an offer of relieving her of “the huge burden” of her virginity. And in November 2022, as reported by The New York Times, a woman filed a lawsuit accusing Beatty of sexually abusing and assaulting her when she was 14 and 15 and he was 35. The actor, now 86, did not address the allegation publicly, and there's been no update on the lawsuit since.

If you have experienced sexual assault or abuse and are in need of crisis support, you can call the RAINN Sexual Assault Hotline at 1-800-656-4673 or visit online.rainn.org.