This TV Star Left His Show After "Terrorizing the Set," Producer Says

Dempsey was an original Grey's Anatomy cast member.

About to begin its 18th season, Grey's Anatomy has been on the air since 2005. In those early days, Pompeo's Meredith Grey was a surgical intern who starts an affair with neurosurgeon Derek, known by Meredith and her friends as "McDreamy." In the excerpt from Rice's oral history published by The Hollywood Reporter, several members of the show's creative team explained that Derek wasn't supposed to be a realistic character but a perfect, ideal man.

"There’s a projection [of him] onto me when you come in contact with fans, certainly with the younger and older fans," Dempsey said in his interview for the book. "There is a certain amount of expectation."

Several of his coworkers agreed that Dempsey lived up to the expectation, calling him "gracious," "charismatic," and "personable." Actor Brooke Smith even noted that Dempsey stood up for her when her character, Erica Hahn, was written off of the show.

But tensions grew as the show went on.

Grey's is one of the longest-running shows in TV history, and the time commitment and routine apparently started to get to Dempsey around the time he left.

Producer Jeannine Renshaw told Rice that Pompeo would get visibly "frustrated" with Dempsey when he would complain about the hours he was required to be on set, especially when she was often needed there even longer.

"When I brought it up to Patrick, I would say, 'Look around you. These people have been here since six thirty a.m.' He would go, 'Oh, yeah.' He would get it," Renshaw said. "It’s just that actors tend to see things from their own perspective. He’s like a kid. He’s so high energy and would go, 'What’s happening next?' He literally goes out of his skin, sitting and waiting. He wants to be out driving his race car or doing something fun. He’s the kid in class who wants to go to recess."

Rice writes that things were so complicated with the actor that former executive producer James D. Parriott was asked to return for Season 11, "to serve as a veritable Dempsey whisperer."

"There were HR issues," Parriott said of Dempsey. "It wasn’t sexual in any way. He sort of was terrorizing the set. Some cast members had all sorts of PTSD with him. He had this hold on the set where he knew he could stop production and scare people. The network and studio came down and we had sessions with them. I think he was just done with the show. He didn’t like the inconvenience of coming in every day and working. He and [creator] Shonda [Rhimes] were at each other’s throats."

For more celebrity news sent right to your inbox, sign up for our daily newsletter.

Eventually, the decision was made to cut Dempsey loose.

Rhimes, who is one of the most powerful creators in Hollywood, was the one to decide that it was time for Dempsey and Grey's Anatomy to part ways.

"A lot of the complaining … I think Shonda finally witnessed it herself, and that was the final straw," Renshaw explained. "Shonda had to say to the network, 'If he doesn’t go, I go.' Nobody wanted him to leave, because he was the show."

According to Parriott, the creative team and ABC even tried to figure out a way to keep Dempsey on the show but separate him from the rest of the cast, especially Pompeo. One idea was that Derek would stay in Washington, D.C., where Derek was for part of Season 11. But the story and production logistics proved to be too challenging.

Dempsey, for his part, wasn't shocked by the news that Derek would be killed off or that he'd no longer be a cast member.

"It was just a natural progression," he said. "And the way everything was unfolding in a very organic way, it was like, 'Okay! This is obviously the right time.' Things happened very quickly. We were like, 'Oh, this is where it’s going to go.'

The twist was such a big secret, many cast members didn't even know he was leaving.

"There was no goodbye party, no goodbye cake," Rice writes of the rainy night during which Dempsey filmed his last scene. Several other actors on the show weren't even aware that he was completing his run as Derek.

Caterina Scorsone, who plays Derek's sister Amelia, said, "I didn’t get to say goodbye to Patrick when he left...When he was suddenly gone from the show, we didn’t have that closure, so I got to play it out."

The director of the episode in which Derek dies, Rob Hardy, said that he didn't see cast members coming to the set to see Dempsey off. Pompeo was there for his last scenes, but it still wasn't a love fest. "We were in the Patrick world, and then Ellen came, and there was definitely a lot of emotion that both of them had individually…not necessarily together," Hardy explained.

Dempsey made a surprise appearance in Season 17.

Despite all the water under the bridge, Dempsey did make a triumphant return to Grey's last season. And no, he wasn't cast as Derek's long-lost twin brother. Meredith contracts COVID in Season 17, which causes her to be in a coma. And in a dreamscape, she encounters many of the show's deceased, including her late love.

Speaking to Variety this April, after another possible final bow for Derek in the Season 17 finale, Dempsey shared that the filming process was much different this time.

"We all cried at the beginning, and we hugged each other," he said of filming his last scene.

He also left the door open to revisit the character again.

"Who knows? Never say never with this show, right? I’m glad we did it this year," he said. "It was just a great way to give people some hope."

RELATED: The Saddest TV Deaths of All Time.