Nobody Is Feeling Scar in the New Live-Action “Lion King” Trailer
What did they do to Scar?!
On Wednesday, Disney released the first full trailer for their remake of The Lion King and it has taken over the internet. But when the live-action film was first announced in 2016, there was some skepticism among fans of the 1994 original animated movie. It seemed a little odd to call it “live action” when it’s 100 percent CGI.
But, for most social media users, those doubts melted away when they saw Simba (voiced by Donald Glover) running to the film’s iconic soundtrack and heard Mufasa (voiced once again by James Earl Jones) say, “While others search for what they can take, a true king searches for what he can give.”
First of all, Simba looks absolutely adorable.
— seni (@irissbloom) April 10, 2019
Everyone can’t wait to hear Nala, voiced by none other than Beyoncé.
— JES (@Jeesseessee) April 10, 2019
And it’s clear Disney has made a notable effort to stay true to some of the most iconic moments of the original movie.
— josie (@emiliaheards) April 10, 2019
But there’s one aspect of the trailer that’s getting largely negative reviews. Scar looks…different.
— The Honorable Joshua Chenault (@joshuachenault1) April 10, 2019
The movie’s villain seems a lot more genuinely terrifying and less comically debonair than he is in the original. And they didn’t keep his fabulous mane, either!
I miss the designs, there ARE black maned lions why scar doesn’t look like this? pic.twitter.com/KUAtsPcYWX
— ko 🧠 OPM HYPE (@SHSL_ANIMATOR) April 10, 2019
For many people whose childhoods were essentially defined by the animated Lion King, this new Scar just isn’t making the cut. He seems a lot less expressive than the original.
Just watched the new trailer for #TheLionKing remake and it made me even more mad about it. They made Scar sound wimpy and he doesn’t even look like Scar. And they made the iconic tree painting look different. why couldn’t they just leave this movie alone. The animated is perfect
— Min Yoongi. Genius (@flameh_) April 10, 2019
One of the great things about the animated Scar is that even though you hated him because he was evil and cruel, he was also a fantastic villain. Some of the best parts of the movie consist of him looking exceptionally bored or throwing some serious side-eye. In comparison, the new Scar feels a bit more one-dimensional.
I’m all for the lion king remake, (mostly because of Donald Glover), but these two pictures highlight how having live action cartoon characters restricts the portrayal of emotion, I mean just look at the picture of scar in the original photo compared to the new one #TheLionKing pic.twitter.com/aFpREnNzY3
— Alistair (@alip1118) April 10, 2019
Then there’s the voice. As an Academy Award nominee, Chiwetel Ejiofor is undeniably a brilliant actor. But it’s hard to replace the silky glory of Jeremy Irons’ timbre and modulation. He simply purred evil, and every one of his lines was somehow both menacing and enticing, which is a very difficult balance to strike.
— Iliesa (@mataiono) April 10, 2019
So, to summarize the overall reaction on social media:
— Karan Jetley (@karanjetley94) April 10, 2019
That being said, perhaps the fact that Scar is so different is a good thing. It seems like the live-action version is going to retain his wrongdoing, but make him more of a sympathetic character. After all, the trailer begins with Scar saying, “Life’s not fair….while some are born to feast, others spend their lives in the dark.”
The best Disney films teach us compassion, and remind us that even villains have feelings and backstories, too.
One way or another, we can’t wait to find out more about the new Scar when the new Lion King hits theaters on July 19! And for more Disney nostalgia, check out 20 Amazing Facts About Disney’s Most Iconic Characters.
To discover more amazing secrets about living your best life, click here to follow us on Instagram!